Do I really need a CMO for my small business?
For most small businesses the answer is no, not yet, and I think you should hear that from someone who sells the role. I'm Daniel Fox, a fractional B2C CMO. You don't need a CMO. You might need the decisions a CMO makes, and only once your activity has outrun those decisions. Until then, hire hands to execute, and go deeper into the customer you already have.
You don't need a CMO; you might need the decisions a CMO makes
The title isn't the point. What you actually need is a set of decisions, and the real question is who is equipped to make them. So start with a plainer test. Does whoever owns your marketing need someone to help develop pieces of copy and graphics, or someone skilled at understanding a customer and their values from first principles, all the way down to the last bit of copy, the punctuation, the color choices, and the campaign, in order to drive revenue?
The first is hands, and the second is the CMO's job. On the surface they ship the same deliverables; the difference is origin. Hands produce assets on request. The CMO reasons from the customer's values down to every detail, with revenue as the goal. You're choosing whether someone executes your existing understanding of the market or derives the work from the customer first.
The three kinds I turn away
I say no to three kinds of small business, and I say it early. The first is a company that isn't at the revenue stage yet. The second is leadership that only wants small tweaks done. The third is leadership that wants somebody with a big title to execute its existing understanding of the market. Two of these are real jobs. They just aren't this one.
The second and third are often well served by a director or a marketing manager, who will take the tweaks off your plate and run the plan you already have. The CMO role is a different job. It takes the whole question off your plate and brings full experience to bear, which means it also reserves the right to challenge the plan. The line is simple. If you want execution of an existing plan, you don't need a CMO. If you want that plan given a critical relook, opened into new possibilities, and tested, that's the job. It's also why a CMO and an agency are not interchangeable, which I cover in do I need a fractional CMO or an agency.
If the answer is not yet, go deeper into the customer you have
The cheapest, most useful thing a too-early company can do costs no retainer. Take the customer you already have and pull apart their value sets. Understand how they have constructed their life, personally and economically, and separate their stated values from their lived values, because the gap between the two is where the marketing that works comes from. This is the work underneath my projective empathy method and my beliefs about customers.
I map this onto Spiral Dynamics, a model of adult values development. It shows how someone's purchases sit inside their goals, and once you understand those values you can speak at any depth, from very deep to very surface, and those depths line up with your funnel. You don't need me to start. You need to actually speak to your customers, and to create a space where criticism of your brand is welcome.
Try to invalidate your own hypothesis.
Most people hesitate to invalidate their own hypothesis, out of the social pressure to be right. Resisting that pressure is most of the work.
Early on, the founder is the right CMO
I've done this job as a founder as well as for clients. I bootstrapped Skreened from 2006, which meant the marketer role was always part of the founder role. I was the CMO the whole way through. I brought in advisors and directed a marketing team beneath me, but I kept the strategic judgment. There was no clean moment where I handed it off. The structure and the role grew up under me.
That's the pattern for a small business that isn't ready. You keep the strategic job yourself and hire hands and advisors under it. You don't hand off the judgment early; you direct execution beneath it. A strategist with nothing to govern is pure cost on the books. The need for a CMO arrives later, when activity has outrun decisions: channels are live, real budget is moving, and no one senior owns whether it's the right work.
Not sure whether you need the role yet?
Tell me where your marketing stands and I'll tell you whether you need a CMO yet, or hands, or just a deeper look at the customer you already have.
Start a conversation